Horse Thief Lake
- Latest confirmed stocking
- Jun 15, 2026Rainbow trout · 1,500 fish for that date
Agency data pulled .
Confirmed in stocking records: Rainbow trout.
Access information is not listed. Check access before you go.
Show water map
Enable JavaScript to load the map.
- Stocked more often than 84% of the 383 South Dakota waters on this site in the last 12 months.
SD GFP logged 3 fish stocking dates at Horse Thief Lake in 2026 so far, 4,500 fish in all. The latest was on Jun 15, 2026. SD GFP lists it as “Horsethief”.
SD GFP data pulled . Latest record in the SD GFP data for any water: Nov 9, 2026.
Stocking totals and dates
Directions
To the map point of the water
Google MapsApple MapsWazeOpens the app or its website. The route starts from where you are.
Horse Thief Lake in numbers
- fish stocked in 2026, through Nov 20
- 4,500
- by the same date in 2025
- 4,500
- in all of 2025
- 4,500
Confirmed stocking by month at Horse Thief Lake
Confirmed reports most often list May: 7 of 24 stocking dates across 7 years. November is outlined.
Every stocking record
Every stocking SD GFP lists for this water, newest first, then yearly totals since 2020. Strain is the hatchery line of the fish (Shasta, Arlee and so on). Size is GFP's class: adults are catchable trout, juveniles, fingerlings and fry are small fish. Fish per pound is GFP's figure; fewer fish per pound means bigger fish. Purpose is why GFP stocked: maintenance stocking is the regular yearly stocking.
| Date | Species | Fish | Strain | Size | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 15 | Rainbow trout0.9 per lb · Adult · Maintenance | 1,500 | 0.9 per lb · Adult | Maintenance | |
| Apr 9 | Rainbow trout1.3 per lb · Adult · Maintenance | 1,500 | 1.3 per lb · Adult | Maintenance | |
| Mar 18 | Rainbow trout0.6 per lb · Adult · Maintenance | 1,500 | 0.6 per lb · Adult | Maintenance |
| Date | Species | Fish | Strain | Size | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 23 | Rainbow trout0.8 per lb · Adult · Maintenance | 1,500 | 0.8 per lb · Adult | Maintenance | |
| Apr 30 | Rainbow trout1 per lb · Adult · Maintenance | 1,500 | 1 per lb · Adult | Maintenance | |
| Mar 20 | Rainbow trout1.3 per lb · Adult · Maintenance | 1,197 | 1.3 per lb · Adult | Maintenance | |
| Mar 20 | Rainbow trout1.2 per lb · Adult · Maintenance | 303 | 1.2 per lb · Adult | Maintenance |
| Year | Stocking dates | Fish |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 3 | 4,500 |
| 2025 | 3 | 4,500 |
| 2024 | 4 | 5,982 |
| 2023 | 5 | 7,500 |
| 2022 | 2 | 4,500 |
| 2021 | 3 | 6,500 |
| 2020 | 4 | 6,495 |
Fish stocked each year
2026 is outlined because the year is not over. The tallest full year is yellow. Counts include fingerlings and fry. Records start in 2020.
What is stocked here
| Species | Fish | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Rainbow trout | 39,977 | 100% |
Where it is
Map point 43.8931, -103.4817: the USGS Geographic Names Information System point for this reservoir (feature 1261840). It marks the water, not a parking lot or a boat launch. Directions lead to that point.
Weather at Horse Thief Lake
Forecast from the National Weather Service (weather.gov) for the map point, loaded in your browser.
Closest waters on this site
Straight-line distance between USGS map points, not driving distance.
Also in Pennington County: Pactola Reservoir, Sheridan Lake, Canyon Lake, Deerfield Lake, Outdoor Campus West Display Pond, Canyon Park Ponds, Sunday Gulch Pond, Rapid Creek - Section 3.
Source: GFP fisheries reports, stocking report by year, South Dakota Game, Fish and Parks. Pulled . Check the agency and the current fishing rules before you go.
Rules and license
Limits, size rules and seasons differ by water and change. These are the official South Dakota Game, Fish and Parks pages; they open in a new tab. Check them before you fish.
Near Horse Thief Lake
Boat access, bait shops, rentals and places to stay within 10 miles. Distances are straight lines from the map point of the water, not driving distance.
Boats, kayaks and marinas
3 within 10 mi- Black Hills Paddlesportscanoe and kayak rental · Hill City5.2 mi
- The Marina At Sheridan Lakemarina · Rapid City6.1 mi
- Sheridan Lakemarina · Mount Rushmore5.6 mi
Campgrounds and RV parks
46 within 10 mi- Kemp's Kampcampground · Keystone1.9 mi
- Holy Smoke ResortRV park · Keystone2.5 mi
- Mount Rushmore KOA Resort at Palmer Gulch Resortcampground · Hill City2.8 mi
- Rushmore View Rv ParkRV park · Keystone2.9 mi
- Under Canvas Mount Rushmorecampground · Keystone3.5 mi
Show all 46
- Castle Peak Campgroundcampground · Hill City4.3 mi
- Three Forks Campgroundcampground · Hill City4.3 mi
- Robins Roost Cabinscampground · Hill City4.4 mi
- Meeting The Needcampground · Keystone5.1 mi
- Sylvan Lake Campgroundcampground · Custer5.3 mi
- Black Hills Trailside Park Resortcampground · Hill City5.3 mi
- Horse Thief Campground & Resortcampground · Hill City5.4 mi
- Hill City / Needles Hwy KOA HolidayRV park · Hill City5.4 mi
- Pine Rest Cabinscampground · Hill City5.4 mi
- Larsson’s Crooked Creek Resortcampground · Hill City5.5 mi
- Crooked Creek Resortcampground · Hill City5.5 mi
- Rafter J Bar Ranchcampground · Hill City5.6 mi
- Creekside Mountain ResortRV park · Hill City5.6 mi
- Larsson's Crooked CreekRV park · Hill City5.6 mi
- Horse Creek Resortcampground · Rapid City6.6 mi
- Oreville Campgroundcampground · West Pennington6.6 mi
- Spokane Creek Cabins & Campgroundcampground · East Custer6.6 mi
- Center Lake Campgroundcampground · Crazy Horse6.7 mi
- Elk Haven Horse Campcampground · Keystone6.8 mi
- Storm Mountain Centercampground · Mount Rushmore7.2 mi
- Gold Valley Campcampground · Custer8.9 mi
- Grace Coolidge CampgroundRV park · Custer9.0 mi
- Custer's Gulch RV ParkRV park · Custer9.1 mi
- Echo Valley Campgroundscampground · Custer9.1 mi
- Fort Welikit Family Campgroundcampground · Custer9.2 mi
- Midwest Outdoor Resortscampground · Rapid City9.3 mi
- Custer's Gulch RV Park and Campgroundcampground · Custer9.4 mi
- The Roost Resortcampground · Custer9.4 mi
- Custer Mountain Cabins & Campgroundcampground · Custer9.4 mi
- Echo Valley Park Campgroundcampground · Custer9.4 mi
- Bearded Buffalo ResortRV park · Custer9.7 mi
- Painted Buffalo Resortscampground · Hermosa10.0 mi
- Grizzly Bear Campgroundcampground · Keystone2.4 mi
- Sheridan Lake Campgroundcampground · Hill City5.4 mi
- Forest Recreation Managementcampground · Hill City5.4 mi
- Wheels WestRV park · Custer8.9 mi
- Legion Lake Campgroundcampground · Custer9.1 mi
- Stockade South Campgroundcampground · Custer9.2 mi
- Stockade Lake South Campgroundcampground · Custer9.2 mi
- Rushmore ShadowsRV park · Rapid City9.5 mi
- Heritage Village Campgroundcampground · Custer9.8 mi
Lodging
66 within 10 mi- Hinterwood Inn & Cabinscabins · Keystone1.2 mi
- American Pines Cabinscabins · Keystone1.6 mi
- Backroads Inn & Cabinscabins · Keystone1.6 mi
- K Bar S Lodgelodge · Keystone2.4 mi
- Powder House Lodgelodge · Keystone2.4 mi
Show all 66
- Rustic Ridge Guest Cabinscabins · Keystone2.5 mi
- Holy Smoke Resortcabins · Keystone2.5 mi
- Powder House Lodge and Restauranthotel · Keystone2.6 mi
- Quality Inn Keystonehotel · Keystone2.7 mi
- Super 8 by Wyndham Keystone/Mt. Rushmoreresort · Keystone2.8 mi
- Keystone Boardwalk Inn and Suiteslodge · Keystone2.8 mi
- Roosevelt Innhotel · Keystone2.8 mi
- Travelodge by Wyndham Mt. Rushmore/Keystonehotel · Keystone2.8 mi
- Ramadahotel · Keystone2.8 mi
- Magnuson Grand Rushmore View Innhotel · Keystone2.9 mi
- Rushmore Express Inn & Family Suiteshotel · Keystone2.9 mi
- Battle Creek Lodgelodge · Keystone3.0 mi
- Holiday Inn Express and Suites Mount Rushmore/Keystonehotel · Keystone3.0 mi
- Comfort Inn & Suiteshotel · Keystone3.0 mi
- The Brookside Motelmotel · Keystone3.2 mi
- Black Elk Resortresort · Rapid City3.4 mi
- Freedom Ridge Cabinscabins · Hill City3.5 mi
- Yak Ridge Guest Cabinshotel · Rapid City3.6 mi
- Creekside Country Resorthotel · Hill City4.0 mi
- Mountain View Lodge & Cabinslodge · Hill City4.0 mi
- Cabins at Creeksidecabins · Hill City4.1 mi
- Double Diamond Ranchlodge · Rapid City4.3 mi
- Janssen's Lodestone Motel & Cabinshotel · Hill City4.6 mi
- Spring Creek Inncabins · Hill City4.7 mi
- Best Western Golden Spike Inn & Suiteshotel · Hill City5.1 mi
- Comfort Inn and Suites Near Mount Rushmorehotel · Hill City5.1 mi
- Super 8 by Wyndham Hill City/Mt Rushmore/ Arearesort · Hill City5.1 mi
- Lantern Innmotel · Hill City5.2 mi
- AmericInn by Wyndham Hill City Mt Rushmoreresort · Hill City5.2 mi
- EverSpring Inn & Suiteshotel · Hill City5.2 mi
- Quality Inn Near Mount Rushmoreresort · Hill City5.3 mi
- Alice's Black Hills Cottage on the Mickhotel · Hill City5.3 mi
- Hillside Country Cabinscabins · Rapid City5.3 mi
- Sylvan Lake Lodgelodge · Custer5.4 mi
- Alpine Inninn · Hill City5.4 mi
- Black Hills Cabins and Motel at Quail's Crossingresort · Hill City5.4 mi
- Super 8 Hill City Mount Rushmore Areahotel · Hill City5.5 mi
- Trails End Cabins & Motelcabins · Hill City5.5 mi
- Buffalo Rock Lodge & Cabinslodge · Keystone5.5 mi
- Restmore Inncabins · Custer5.6 mi
- McDonald Mountain Ranchlodge · Keystone5.8 mi
- Newton Fork Ranchcabins · Hill City5.9 mi
- Silver Mountain Resort & Cabinscabins · Rapid City6.0 mi
- Little Red Innhotel · Custer6.8 mi
- Black Hills Bungalowscabins · Custer7.4 mi
- Rockerville Gold Town Lodginglodge · Rockerville7.5 mi
- Rockerville Lodge & Cabinslodge · Rockerville7.6 mi
- Stockade Lake Cabincabins · Custer8.8 mi
- Mickelson Trail Lodginglodge · Hill City8.8 mi
- Calamity Peak Lodgelodge · Custer9.0 mi
- Legion Lake Lodgelodge · Custer9.1 mi
- Svenmar Nightly Rentalscabins · Keystone1.5 mi
- Dee'zz Innlodge · Keystone2.3 mi
- The Lodge At Mount Rushmorehotel · Keystone2.5 mi
- Mt Rushmore's Washington Innhotel · Keystone2.7 mi
- Mount Rushmore's White House Resortresort · Keystone2.8 mi
- Black Hills Vacation Lodginghotel · Hill City4.3 mi
- Jade Placehotel · Hill City4.7 mi
- Alphine Inn Hill City Sdhotel · Hill City5.4 mi
- Lowrey Lodgehotel · Hill City5.5 mi
- Valley Motelhotel · Custer9.5 mi
Businesses: Overture Maps Foundation open places data (release 2026-10-21.0, pulled 2026-11-09), from the businesses’ public listings. We have not visited them and do not rank them. Hours and services change, so call ahead.
Fished Horse Thief Lake?
Tell other anglers how it went: what was biting, the access, the crowds. It takes a minute, no sign-up.